A new report released to the ABC has revealed how the
$60 billion Westfield shopping centre group does so well financially,
showing the firm's main UK company has paid only a small fraction of its
revenue in tax.
More than 50 Westfield subsidiaries are based in the low-tax haven of Jersey in the English Channel.
The
report argues the governments of the world should crack down on tax
minimising ways of big corporations like Westfield, to reduce debt and
deficit.
Westfield UK operates Europe's largest urban shopping
centre, but having a net tax liability of less than half a million
pounds over more than a decade to 2011, it must also have one of the
lowest corporate tax rates compared to its multi-billion dollar revenue
over that period.
Richard Murphy runs Tax Research, a UK consultancy that does what its name suggests on behalf of charities and unions.
Westfield UK operates Europe's largest urban shopping centre, but
having a net tax liability of less than half a million pounds over more
than a decade to 2011, it must also have one of the lowest corporate tax
rates compared to its multi-billion dollar revenue over that period.
Richard Murphy runs Tax Research, a UK consultancy that does what its name suggests on behalf of charities and unions.
"Westfield has put in place what they would
call a tax-efficient structure and that must only be because they are
looking to save tax," he said.
"I've been a chartered accountant for 31 years now. I reckon I've read 10,000 sets of accounts or more in my time."
Recently, he added the accounts of Westfield Shoppingtowns Ltd, the group's main UK subsidiary, to that list.
What Mr Murphy found was a labyrinthine structure.
"There is a legal entity that owns the site which is UK resident, but
it actually does so on behalf of a group of Jersey property unit
trusts. They're called J-PUTS for short," he said.
Mr Murphy can only think of one good reason for those layers of subsidiaries.
"Let's be blunt about it: nobody would use a Jersey property unit trust if it wasn't for a tax motive," he said.
Asked
about the tax benefits of using something like a Jersey property unit
trust, he says: "Well, one thing to say straight away is it does not
mean that Westfield does not pay tax in the UK on its rental income in
this country."
But there are other likely tax benefits, he says.
"First
of all, it appears that these trusts will actually make the flow of
income with a reduced rate of tax, or as low a possible rate of tax,
easier for Westfield," he said.
"The second incentive is actually
capital gains tax. Under current UK law there would be no capital gains
tax charge because capital gains are charged on where the company is
resident, not where the property is, and these companies are not
resident in the UK.
"The Jersey property unit trust is not in the UK and therefore capital gain, if one is made on sale, would fall out of tax.
"And
there's another advantage as well with regard to sale: the J-PUT will
prevent stamp duty being paid. So there's some very strong property tax
avoidance opportunities made available by using a J-PUT which the UK
equivalent structures cannot provide."
Westfield Group has 54 subsidiary companies registered in Jersey
Mr Murphy has noticed one other interesting issue with the relationship between Westfield UK and the Jersey trusts.
The
trusts were paying for Westfield's UK shopping centre developments but
the payments were often months late, meaning the UK company incurred
more interest costs which it then deducted against its income for tax.
"As
a result, Westfield Shoppingtowns Ltd was incurring heavy borrowing
costs in the UK on which it was claiming tax relief, cancelling its
profits, cancelling its tax liabilities, in that sense, as a result," Mr
Murphy said.
"And the consequence of that was that the Jersey company was effectively being funded by not paying the UK company."
The
global Westfield Group clearly likes Jersey's regulatory system: so
much so that it has 54 subsidiary companies registered there, according
to a study conducted by the Uniting Church earlier this year.
Dr
Mark Zirnsak, who led that research, said: "It was a company that chose
not to engage with us at all. So they offered us no explanation as to
why they had subsidiaries in secrecy jurisdictions and particularly the
one they made greatest use of was Jersey in the Channel Islands. So they
had 54 subsidiaries in Jersey by our understanding."
Company is acting entirely within tax laws
However, both researchers say that Westfield is acting entirely within the tax laws as they exist.
"As
far as I'm concerned, everything that has gone on here is legal. All
I'm doing is drawing attention to the fact that these arrangements
exist," Mr Murphy said.
Michael Crosby, the national president of
the United Voice union which commissioned the report, says not
everything that is legal is moral.
"The whole community benefits from the payment of tax. That's where we get government services from," he said.
"And
the quality of life of the people we represent at the bottom of the
labour market really depends upon whether big business pays their tax."
And
he says Westfield's attitude to paying tax reflects its attitude to
United Voice members, with the company failing to support the union's
call for better pay and conditions for cleaners.
"Cleaners are not
the voiceless people that Westfield thought they were. They've got a
powerful union and we're using that power to defend them," Mr Crosby
said.
In response to emailed questions from the ABC, Westfield
says it has always complied with all its tax requirements in all
jurisdictions.
It says it cannot offer a detailed response to any
of the issues in the study until the report is released and it can view
it in its entirety.
abc.net.au 16 Oct 2013
The government will never prosecute nor even try to go after their multinational colleagues, who own tens of companies linked to one retailer for the sole purpose of tax 'evasion'.
What the governments WILL do is if anyone from the general population opens accounts, this information is passed on to the relevant government, and they are dealt with accordingly.